Publications

For Australians diagnosed with cancer, trauma insurance can provide vital financial support at a time of enormous personal and emotional strain. Unfortunately, many patients discover that claiming trauma cover is not straightforward. Policies vary widely, and insurers often rely on highly technical definitions that can exclude certain types of cancer or delay payment. Understanding how these policies work and the common pitfalls can make a significant difference to your chances of a successful claim.

Not all cancers are covered, the importance for understanding the definitions

Most trauma insurance policies cover what they call “malignant cancer”, but this term is defined narrowly. Conditions such as non-invasive cancers, low-grade tumours and skin cancers (unless they are invasive melanomas) are often excluded. Even where a policy does not clearly exclude a particular diagnosis, the insured person must still meet the specific medical definition contained in the policy to receive a payment.

The definition of “cancer” may require histological confirmation, evidence that the disease has invaded surrounding tissue, and a clear distinction between invasive and pre-cancerous conditions. These technical requirements can be confusing, and many people with early-stage cancers are surprised to learn that they do not qualify for a full trauma benefit. For example, some policies provide only a partial payment for early-stage breast or prostate cancer. Reading and understanding your policy’s definition of cancer before making a claim is therefore critical.

Timing matters, watch the waiting period

Timing is another common trap. Most trauma policies include a waiting period, often around 90 days from the commencement of cover. If the diagnosis occurs within that period, the claim may be denied. It is important to confirm the start date of your policy and to check whether any symptoms or investigations began before the cover took effect. Insurers may argue that a condition was pre-existing if there is evidence that symptoms were present prior to the commencement of the policy.

Pre-existing conditions, the importance of disclosure

Insurers may be entitled to deny claims where there has been non-disclosure of relevant medical information. If you experienced symptoms, had tests, or received treatment for a condition related to cancer before taking out the policy, the insurer may rely on that to reject the claim. In some cases, insurers go back through medical records and point to notes from a GP or earlier scans to argue that the cancer existed before cover began, even if you were unaware of it.

If this occurs, it is important to seek legal advice. The insurer bears the burden of proving that you knew, or ought to have known, about the condition at the time of applying for the policy. Many denials on this basis can be successfully challenged with proper evidence and legal argument.

Medical evidence must match the policy definition

Another reason claims are sometimes declined is that the medical evidence provided does not align with the technical requirements of the policy. Insurers assess trauma claims not on the fact that you have been diagnosed with cancer, but on whether the medical findings satisfy their contractual definition of a “covered condition”.

To meet this test, it is crucial that your treating specialist or oncologist provides a report addressing the type, grade, and stage of the cancer, including the histopathology results and whether the condition meets the definition used in your policy. A brief diagnosis letter will rarely be sufficient. Insurers routinely ask for detailed pathology reports and specialist opinions, so preparing this information carefully at the outset can prevent delays and disputes.

Partial benefits — knowing what you’re entitled to

Some trauma policies provide tiered benefits, offering a full payment for invasive cancers and a partial payment for early-stage or low-grade cancers. Even if your diagnosis does not meet the strict definition for a full trauma benefit, it is still worth asking whether a partial benefit applies. These payments, while smaller, can still offer valuable financial assistance during treatment and recovery, particularly where income has been affected.

Psychological impact is not covered

Despite the name “trauma insurance”, these policies do not provide cover for the psychological trauma of a cancer diagnosis unless the Policy has specified TPD cover as a Claimed condition (Trauma cover).

Trauma cover usually applies only to physical medical conditions that satisfy the policy definitions. Many patients are understandably distressed by their diagnosis and assume that trauma cover will respond to the emotional impact. Unfortunately, unless the physical illness meets the criteria for a covered condition, claims based solely on psychological harm will not succeed.

Many trauma claims are denied for technical reasons that can be challenged. A lawyer experienced in insurance disputes can assist by interpreting complex policy definitions, obtaining and presenting appropriate medical evidence, and communicating directly with the insurer.

At Carroll & O’Dea Lawyers, we offer free initial consultations, no-win no-fee arrangements for trauma insurance claims, and practical support for patients and families navigating what is often a confusing and stressful process.

This article was published on 24 November by Carroll & O’Dea Lawyers and is based on the relevant state of the law (legislation, regulations and case law) at that date for the jurisdiction in which it is published. Please note this article does not constitute legal advice. If you ever need legal advice or want to discuss a legal problem, please contact us to see if we can help. You can reach us on 1800 059 278 or via the Contact us page on our website.